There’s a peculiar quality of silence that comes when you’ve spent five years mostly alone with your thoughts, your books, and a question you can’t stop asking.
Not the peaceful quiet of morning fog or the productive silence of focused work. I’m talking about the kind that emerges when the universe backs you into a corner and won’t let you leave, no matter how politely you ask, until you’ve figured something out.
For me, that question was, and remains: What is love?
Not the feeling. Not the action. Not the biochemistry or the poetry or the thousand synonyms we use because we can’t quite name the thing itself. But the actual phenomenon at the center of human existence that everyone claims to know and yet no one can universally define.
For more than a decade, Toni, my wife of 43 years, and I rode 100,000 miles across all 48 states with that question. We sat with neuroscientists and Buddhist monks, advocates for death row inmates and Lakota elders, educators and soldiers, dog trainers and quantum physicists. NPR’s Morning Edition later covered the work. The three companion podcast/radio programs that emerged from our travels, The Love in America Podcast, Love Is History, and Tales from the Heart of America, went out nationally through PRX and are still there. Twenty-five years of teaching had shaped how I think. A lifetime of gardening and laughter shaped hers. We’ve lived the question for 43 years together. And still, when I carried all of it into a time I now call The Hermitage five years ago, I still didn’t know.
Then, I realized that Toni and I weren’t only after love stories. We were after love’s story.
What I’ve emerged with isn’t an answer fit for a bumper sticker. It’s a paradigm shift.
A different way of seeing that changes everything about how we understand love, consciousness, meaning, connection, and why we’re here at all.
That work has become a book: A Map of Souls: The Quest for Love’s True Story. It is making its way toward publication. This Cartographer’s Log is where I write alongside that journey, in the open, in the meantime, with you. And when I go too deep in the weeds with it all, Toni will come along and pull us both out with a poke and a chuckle.
What This Log Is
The Cartographer’s Log is our attempt to share what we’ve found about love’s true nature and role in our lives without turning it into dogma or self-help platitudes. Field notes from a couple who’ve been mapping the territory and want to compare lines with fellow travelers.
Some of what I share here comes from rigorous interdisciplinary research: consciousness studies, quantum physics, neuroscience, epigenetics, and contemplative wisdom. Much comes from the hundreds of conversations Toni and I had on the road. Still more comes from the hard-earned wisdom of surviving addiction and violence, of teaching middle schoolers, of staying married through decades that pulled so many other unions I love apart. And a bit will come from Toni’s gift for tears of laughter, grief, joy, and hope - all of which she can share and honor in the same remarkable breath.
All of it points to the same radical proposition: that love isn’t just something we feel or do. It is the motive and creative aspect of consciousness itself, the reason existence has meaning, the ground from which everything else emerges. The reason God gets up in the morning.
We humans are not broken animals trying to behave. We are expressions of universal Love learning what it means to be through every choice, every relationship, every moment of experience, connection, or isolation.
I know how that sounds. Trust me, the science teacher, biker, elder, and cynic in me struggled with this understanding for years. But the evidence kept stacking up. Eventually, I had to admit that the materialist map I’d been handed, the one that says consciousness is just brain chemistry and love is just an epiphenomenon of evolution, simply doesn’t account for what we actually experience; the sum of our travels on this map of souls. Toni knew and lived it intuitively; I had to find its foundation and discover what made it stand up. Together, we’ve got a story to tell: love’s story.
And what changes when you understand what love actually is?
Everything.
This isn’t a lecture series, though. We’re not here to convert anyone. What we’re offering is a different lens, a new chart, and an invitation to test it against your own experience.
Who This Is For
This Log is for seekers. I mean that broadly and without apology.
If you suspect that love is far more than sentiment and transaction, more than the narrow accounts and wider judgments the culture has settled for, you’ll find affirmation here.
If you carry genuine care for the work of being human in a world grown thin on meaning, whether you do that work in a classroom, a hospital, a sanctuary, a family, a friendship, your own solitude, or all of the above, you’ll find community here.
If you’ve been told you have to choose between rigorous thinking and devoted attention to what’s most sacred, and you’ve quietly refused to choose, you’ll find understanding here.
If you’re wrestling with questions about consciousness in an age of artificial intelligence, about purpose in an age of metrics, about long love in a culture that has forgotten how to keep almost anything, you’ll find hope here.
Some weeks, Toni or I will tell stories from the road or the classroom, and others, I’ll dig into the science or the philosophy. Sometimes, we’ll write more personally, from the place where we have made over four decades of marriage hold up to the question we set out to ask of the country: What is Love?
All of it sits inside one inquiry, written from two perspectives, addressed to one community: human.
An Invitation
Here’s what we’re not promising: easy answers, quick fixes, Hallmark cards, or a five-step program to anything.
Here’s what we are offering: honest exploration of the most vital question human beings ask, grounded in a biker’s creed: Don’t be an a**hole. Be grateful for the miles you are given. Always stop when another rider needs help on the road.
You’ll find both rigorous inquiry and lived experience here, shared by a man who has earned his scars and who sees and honors yours, and a woman who knows that laughter and tears are the music of love and is happy to sing along with you.
The Hermitage taught me that confusion is often more valuable than certainty, and that honestly not knowing can be the perfect condition for actually learning something. Once you have earned that treasure, you have a duty to share it. I’ll bring that same spirit to everything I write here. And Toni will remind us when time would be better spent petting a dog, putting a dollar in the plate, and blowing on a dandelion to watch the seeds go and find new life.
And whatever you take away from this Log, and for whatever we learn from you in turn, we’re grateful to be here with you, together. We are pack.
The map is being drawn. The compass rose is set. I’ve emerged from this quiet corner with something worth sharing. And there’s laughter breaking the silence.
Let’s see where the road goes.
With love,
Scotte
Welcome to A Map of Souls: Cartographer’s Log. Subscribe to join the journey.
Welcome to A Map of Souls: Cartographer’s Log. Subscribe to join the journey
.



